I got rubbed the wrong way by those. Perhaps it's seeing 2 commentaries by abstinent 16 year olds, instead of one by an active teen and one by an abstinent teen...
Perhaps it's that they're citing the same (preventable) reasons for being abstinent - reasons that aren't given honest appraisal in most current sex ed programs.
I think it's safe to assume that they've gotten these notions through piss-poor sex education, and probably stringent parents.
Does any one else find it troubling that two teenage girls would be chosen to self-describe as abstinent, yet there aren't any abstinent guys among the commentaries?
Or the fact that pregnancy and STDs, while being real risks that we're all aware of, are preventable with commitment and a basic amount of effort? Why the focus on these risks, and not the risk of an abusive relationship or one that's otherwise unhealthy?
Posts: 455 | From: New York, NY | Registered: Apr 2005
| IP: Logged |
I don't know if you read all 16 articles or not, but I did, and I found some other very interesting things: (Cylcling down from the 3rd article)
Article 1: The Gay Rights one - girl Article 2: Anorexia - girl Article 3: Said very little, talked about blogging and becoming a grown up - girl Article 4: Balancing extra-curriculars, sports, and GPA (marks, percentages, the numbers) - girl Article 5: After the first line, I was already biased to read the rest of the article as invalid:
quote:The main reason I am abstinent is I don’t want to become pregnant.
A) Sex interaction other than vaginal sex B) Condoms or other contraceptives. Since she apparently does not know of the existence of either of these, I doubt she is well educated enough to be putting forth any opinion on sex. She later says "They do know about birth control, but I'm not sure they use it." - I don't understand how a girl acknowledges and ignores BC in the same piece of writing. - girl Article 6: Becoming your own person - since this 16 year old refers to Darfur, I am rather impressed. - The first male Article 7: Another biased article about sex - girl Article 8: Racism - boy #2 Article 9: Standardized Testing - Girl #7 Article 10: Globalization, pollution, world stances - boy #3 Article 11: High school and related pressures - Girl #8 Article 12: High school, college, and related pressures - Girl #9 Article 13: Melodrama (the first article) contains the line "boys are infantile", which I especially appreciate. Nothing like a little discrimination to augment ones opinions. - Girl #10 (This is Ana Baric, flipped over at the top) Article 14: Pressures on students, being caught between two age groups. Boy #4 Article 15: Stress, competition, and high school. Boy #5 Article 16: Paying for University/College, Joining the army. Boy #6
Now, there are several things to point out.
Only 3 of the articles are directly about sex. A few others contain passing references. What does this say about the age-old "teen age focus on sex?"
The fact 16 people equals 10 girls and 6 guys. Are only 375 out of 1000 sixteen year olds actually guys, or is this disproportionate representation? Furthermore, another concern is: 3 of the guys discuss school, education, and pressures on teens. The other three cover: racism, global politics, and growing into an individual. On the girls side, 6 talked about school, 1 anorexia, 2 sex, 1 gay marriage. In each sample group, 3 people hit controversial/major topics, showing a bias or slant trying to imply that girls don't care as much about the rest of the world as guys - which I disagree with.
I agree that a lack of abstinant guys is a problem. Especially because people's idea of abstinence varies from - nothing past kissing, to anything but vaginal sex.
-------------------- 19, male, interested in Sadomasochism (BDSM) and some bisexual tendancies. Posts: 157 | From: Canada | Registered: Jan 2006
| IP: Logged |
It would have been nice to hear from an abstinent guy. My husband was abstinent until we were married; guys like that do exist (whether remaining abstinent until marriage, or at least until they're more grown up).
I also agree that other reasons should be discussed. Pregnancy was an issue for me; I know that nothing is 100% except abstinence, and in my rural small-town it would have been a pretty big deal if I got pregnant as a teen (since I was a "smart kid"). However, I waited for religious reasons, too. And because I'm a romantic. And maybe because I'm a bit selfish (he had to BUY this cow! lol). I kind of resent it when the abstinence issue is presented so one dimensionally.
Posts: 81 | From: MO, USA | Registered: Mar 2003
| IP: Logged |
Copyright 1998, 2014 Heather Corinna/Scarleteen
Scarleteen.com: Providing comprehensive sex education online to teens and young adults worldwide since 1998
Information on this site is provided for educational purposes. It is not meant to and cannot substitute for advice or care provided by an in-person medical professional. The information contained herein is not meant to be used to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease, or for prescribing any medication. You should always consult your own healthcare provider if you have a health problem or medical condition.